New Markets Advisors
  • About
    • Our Distinct Model
    • Team
    • Join Us
  • Services
    • Develop Growth Strategies
    • Uncover Jobs to be Done
    • Build Innovation Capabilities
  • Industries
    • Arts and Culture
    • Consumer Goods
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Social Innovation
    • Technology
  • Past Work
    • Success Stories
    • Recent Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Our Thinking
    • Leading through the Coronavirus Crisis
    • Books
    • Working Papers
    • Articles
    • Blog
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Contact

New Markets Insights
​
Strategy and Analysis from Innovation Specialists

Apple's Business Model Vulnerability, Exposed by a French Upstart

4/18/2012

 
This blog first appeared as Steve Wunker’s piece for Forbes
 
By: Steve Wunker​
Free Mobile is a company few Americans have heard of, yet it is up-ending Apple's prospects in France.  Analysts are blaming the firm for driving down iPhone sales by 10% in the past quarter alone.  How?
Free is a classic example of "disruptive innovation," a term coined by my mentor Clayton Christensen.  The company is offering unlimited domestic calls and texts, free calls to many international countries, 3 GB of data per month, and no contract commitment -- all for $25 a month.  In exchange for this exceptionally good deal, subscribers give up some of the benefits associated with traditional mobile carriers.  Verizon and AT&T are two of the world's biggest advertisers, while Free barely advertises at all.  Traditional carriers can invest massively in proprietary applications; Free doesn't.  Most critically, carriers often subsidize handset prices by hundreds of dollars, but Free doesn't subsidize handsets at all.  If you want a new phone, you buy one yourself without it being tied to any carrier ("SIM-free").
​
As often happens with disruptive innovations, the incumbents initially downplayed the upstart's significance.  No longer.  Free has won nearly 3 million subscribers in its first three months, and the incumbents are facing intense price pressure.  Carriers around the world are taking notice.  Many have resisted becoming a "dumb pipe" for communications, wanting to believe that they could earn a price premium through distinctive services and brands.  Free has demonstrated the latent demand for a cheap, reliable, dumb pipe.  It seems only a matter of time before the model is replicated in country after country.

This is a major problem for Apple.  The most basic iPhone 4S sells for €629 without the carrier subsidy, while entry-level Android and Windows phones are priced around €299.  Unsurprisingly, people who have to pay the full price for a handset flock to the less expensive, and technically quite solid, Android and Windows offerings.  The iPhone has always been expensive, reliant upon big subsidies from carriers trying to stand out from their competitors.  Strip away the subsidy and Apple either has to cut price dramatically, decimating its profit margins, or accept a much lower market share.

Either way, the iPhone's struggles could have a big impact on the rest of Apple's offerings.  Think of the people you know who own an iPad -- which ones don't also own an iPhone?  The iPhone is the lynchpin of Apple's presence in consumers' lives.  Without the synchronization, apps, and constant usage of an iPhone, there isn't much need to own the full complement of Apple products.

Companies can parry technological threats through savvy engineering.  They can meet marketing threats through upping their spending and better segmenting their customers.  But business model threats?  The record for incumbents is very poor.  Apple doesn't have many good options if Free's model spreads.  All the brilliant engineering and marketing in Cupertino can't compensate for a business model rooted in carrier strategies that seem increasingly outdated.

Comments are closed.

    This section will not be visible in live published website. Below are your current settings:


    Current Number Of Columns are = 3

    Expand Posts Area =

    Gap/Space Between Posts = 10px

    Blog Post Style = card

    Use of custom card colors instead of default colors =

    Blog Post Card Background Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Shadow Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Border Color = current color

    Publish the website and visit your blog page to see the results

Picture

ABOUT
Our Distinct Model
​Team
​Join

SERVICES
dEVELOP growth strategIES
UNCOVER JOBS TO BE DONE 
BUILD INNOVATION CAPABILITIES


​​

INDUSTRIES
Arts and culture
​consumer goods 
financial services
healthcare
Social Innovation
Technology

​

PAST WORK
success Stories
recent clients
Testimonials

OUR THINKING
Leading through the coronavirus
books
working papers
articles
blog
SPEAKING ENGAGEMENTS

NEW MARKETS ADVISORS
50 Franklin Street
​Second Floor
Boston, MA 02110
United States

Tel. +1 617 936 4035

Contact Us

New Markets Advisors: Empowering Companies to COMPETE DIFFERENTLY ​© Copyright 2021. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use. PRIVACY POLICY.
  • About
    • Our Distinct Model
    • Team
    • Join Us
  • Services
    • Develop Growth Strategies
    • Uncover Jobs to be Done
    • Build Innovation Capabilities
  • Industries
    • Arts and Culture
    • Consumer Goods
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Social Innovation
    • Technology
  • Past Work
    • Success Stories
    • Recent Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Our Thinking
    • Leading through the Coronavirus Crisis
    • Books
    • Working Papers
    • Articles
    • Blog
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Contact