New Markets Advisors
  • About
    • Our Distinct Model
    • Team
    • Join Us
  • Services
    • Develop Growth Strategies
    • Uncover Jobs to be Done
    • Build Innovation Capabilities
  • Industries
    • Arts and Culture
    • Consumer Goods
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Social Innovation
    • Technology
  • Past Work
    • Success Stories
    • Recent Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Our Thinking
    • Leading through the Coronavirus Crisis
    • Books
    • Working Papers
    • Articles
    • Blog
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Contact

New Markets Insights
​
Strategy and Analysis from Innovation Specialists

Healthcare’s Lack of Transparency and its Impact on Market Creation

6/16/2010

 
By: New Markets Advisors
Picture
Transparency promotes market creation. If customers can understand the quality and cost of new propositions, they can assess whether the offering is a good fit for them. 
The greater the number of people who can make this assessment, the more likely it is that some segment of customers will find it attractive. Moreover, if customers have direct exposure to this information they can overcome the inertia often found in gatekeeper-oriented systems, where a relative handful of individuals makes decisions about what to bring to market based on sometimes misaligned criteria.
​
Teeth whitening works this way. The results of whitening are immediately obvious and the cost is clear. What started out as a procedure performed only in dental offices has migrated into several new markets such as shopping mall boutiques, home whitening kits, and touch up pens. Innovation blossomed.
​
The American healthcare system is not transparent in its medical outcomes, service quality, or pricing. Its customers, whether these are defined as patients or their employers, often have little idea of whether they are receiving good value. Gatekeepers — doctors, hospital purchasing departments, health insurers and others — determine whether new offerings should succeed in the marketplace. This makes sense to some extent. Consumers can’t judge whether a new way of performing a surgical procedure is right for them. But because the system reduces the chance for markets to segment, it lowers the probability that innovative offerings will find a viable foothold. Inertia also results from the many layers of decision-makers.

A company called Castlight Health is trying to change that. It has just announced that it raised $60 million from leading investors, including the Cleveland Clinic to become a “Travelocity of Healthcare” for patients and employers. It wants to list online the prices of procedures from a host of competitive providers, gleaning that data from Explanation of Benefits forms.

This is a laudable idea, but it is hard to see it working in the healthcare system we have today. There are currently over 7,000 billing codes, and that number is set to expand by an order of magnitude in the coming years. It is a very complex system to comprehend. Moreover, even for an apples-to-apples comparison of procedures, providers will bill very different rates depending upon what they have negotiated with health insurers. One of a health insurer’s main functions is to negotiate these rates, ensure appropriate billing, and monitor quality. It is not clear why this responsibility should be transferred to patients and employers. Costs can vary inordinately between providers for the same procedure, but insurers have strong incentives to negotiate those differentials away or drop the expensive providers from their networks. This is true whether the insurer is carrying the risk or just performing administrative services for a self-insured employer.

A better approach is to have more transparency in quality. Massachusetts, for instance, makes doctor quality data available to patients online, and sites like Healthgrades.com allows patients to make subjective quality assessments on criteria such as trust in the doctor and whether the doctor helps patients make informed decisions. This data can help patients choose where to seek treatment no matter what procedure they need.
Another good approach is for employers and their insurers to have very tightly-managed networks of physicians, possibly including an on-site clinic at large companies. In these systems cost and quality can be more easily controlled, good performance can be rewarded, and innovative offerings can take root by running a shorter gauntlet of decision-makers than is otherwise the case. Patients do not have to worry about cost comparison because their employers and insurers have incentives to keep costs low and the tools to maintain high quality. In a closely-aligned system, costs and outcomes are highly transparent to the key decision-makers. If patients are concerned that the resulting lack of physician choice is leading to poor care, they can make their case to people who have the power and information to do something about it.

While transparency is an important precursor to market creation, it can take different forms depending on industry context. Healthcare may not need a Travelocity. It does need a closer coupling between employer, insurer, physician and patient to foster competition and create a more fertile ground for valuable innovations.

Story by Steve Wunker.


Comments are closed.

    This section will not be visible in live published website. Below are your current settings:


    Current Number Of Columns are = 3

    Expand Posts Area =

    Gap/Space Between Posts = 10px

    Blog Post Style = card

    Use of custom card colors instead of default colors =

    Blog Post Card Background Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Shadow Color = current color

    Blog Post Card Border Color = current color

    Publish the website and visit your blog page to see the results

Picture

ABOUT
Our Distinct Model
​Team
​Join

SERVICES
dEVELOP growth strategIES
UNCOVER JOBS TO BE DONE 
BUILD INNOVATION CAPABILITIES


​​

INDUSTRIES
Arts and culture
​consumer goods 
financial services
healthcare
Social Innovation
Technology

​

PAST WORK
success Stories
recent clients
Testimonials

OUR THINKING
Leading through the coronavirus
books
working papers
articles
blog
SPEAKING ENGAGEMENTS

NEW MARKETS ADVISORS
50 Franklin Street
​Second Floor
Boston, MA 02110
United States

Tel. +1 617 936 4035

Contact Us

New Markets Advisors: Empowering Companies to COMPETE DIFFERENTLY ​© Copyright 2021. All Rights Reserved. Terms of Use. PRIVACY POLICY.
  • About
    • Our Distinct Model
    • Team
    • Join Us
  • Services
    • Develop Growth Strategies
    • Uncover Jobs to be Done
    • Build Innovation Capabilities
  • Industries
    • Arts and Culture
    • Consumer Goods
    • Financial Services
    • Healthcare
    • Social Innovation
    • Technology
  • Past Work
    • Success Stories
    • Recent Clients
    • Testimonials
  • Our Thinking
    • Leading through the Coronavirus Crisis
    • Books
    • Working Papers
    • Articles
    • Blog
    • Speaking Engagements
  • Contact